I believe that both Madie and Alex brought up valid points, and we all seem to mostly be in agreement with each other on the events that occurred in this chapter. I think that Madie brought up an interesting point by stating how Katerina is only so depressed at Marmeladov's death because she is used to having him around, since even during his last moments she keeps criticizing him. It is true that Marmeladov brings barely any income to his family as he wastes it all on alcohol, which is why i agree that Katerina is just so used to the lifestyle and doesn't want to lose him. I also agree that Marmeladov assists them emotionally and financially in order to redeem his sins. However, he did help this family out before he had anything to feel guilty about which shows that he is, in fact, a compassionate character. This is all very contradictory because he demonstrates several characteristics that a good-natured, caring man would have, but his mistake in committing the murders over powers all of his good deeds, and he knows it. I agree that he will continue to attempt to clear his conscience with good deeds, but in the end nothing will be able to make up for his crime. I agree with Alex when she stated how she believes that no matter what he does, he will be unable to feel completely guilt free and will eventually pay for his actions even after he confesses.
-Gabriel Magalhaes
No comments:
Post a Comment