I believe Madie's review on chapters 1-3 was very accurate and I strongly agree with her. The author does not reveal the protagonist's name within the first few pages. This allows the reader to focus on the details surrounding his life and personality while creating suspense and curiosity. Marmeladov's character creates controversy. While his intentions were to help his family, he had an uncontrollable addiction to alcohol that prevented them from exiting the poverty lifestyle multiple times. As soon as he was offered a job, he disposed of his chances of success by drinking away his money. It was almost as if he was incapable of maintaining a successful lifestyle. However, Madie stated that he knew what the right thing to do was. This is the only part where I disagree. Although he may have had all the best intentions by finding a job and attempting to support his family, he was a terrible father for allowing his daughter to prostitute herself to increase the family income as this is never a proper resort regardless of the situation. It is true that it is impossible to predict the outcome of the novel, however, judging by his negative reaction to his mother's letter I predict that Raskolikov will not allow his sister to marry this man due to not only his pride but his concern for his family's well being. I agree with Madie that at some point in the novel that he and the groom will not get along and will most likely engage in some form of altercation.
-Gabriel Magalhaes
No comments:
Post a Comment